Showing posts with label Random thoughts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Random thoughts. Show all posts

Friday, February 15, 2008

Cause and Effect and Self Fulfilling Prophecy

I have been thinking about the "cause-and-effect" phenomenon in the social context. Simply put, an event-A happens, which causes or triggers event-B. Newton's Third Law (Every action has an equal and opposite reaction.) can be explained in laymen's term as: Every action has consequences. Interestingly, the Hindu philosophy takes this scientific rule and apply it to everyday life. The laws of karma imply that your current living conditions (good or bad) are actually caused by your karma (deeds, or actions) from your early life or even from your previous birth.


The situation that interests me particularly is: Cause (Event A) --> Effect (Event B) --> Cause (Event A). In other words, Action-A triggers Action-B. But then Action-B becomes trigger for Action-A. The consequence reinforces the original cause. And the wheel can keep turning forever.


I can think of a hypothetical example of a husband and wife. The husband thinks that his wife is not treating him with respect (Event A). Disappointed, he starts drinking and coming home late every day (Event B). But this just makes things worse, and his wife now actually disrespects him (Event A, again). Once this kind of rather vicious cycle is in motion, it becomes impossible to tell where exactly it started. Did the wife not treat her husband well in the beginning? Or was it just a wrong assumption on the husband's part? 


Other examples comes to mind. A minority group in a society finds it difficult to get jobs in spite of having a good level of education (being discriminated and all). So they become less interested in getting college degrees and more involved with petty jobs and joining street gangs and criminal activities. This reinforces the majority group's discriminatory feelings towards the minority. Which, in turn, makes it more difficult for minority folks to get a job. And the vicious cycle continues!


Let's say you hear somewhere that road accidents are more likely to happen when you change lanes. So you try to be extra careful while changing lanes. This wavers your normal driving sense, and you become more likely to make a mistake. An accident happens. And this validates your initial belief (which might not have been true to begin with!).


These example are also related to a phenomenon called "Self fulfilling prophecy".  As explained by the Thomas Theorem: 


"If men defined situations as real, they are real in their consequences."


Take the story of Krishna for example. The king of Mathura, Kansa, hears a prophecy that he will be killed by his sister Devaki's son. So he puts her behind bars and plans to kill all her sons. (Don't ask me why he put both Devaki and Vasudeva in the same cell!) So Kansa kills Devaki's first six children. But the seventh (or was it 8th?) child Krishna was smuggled out of the prison. And eventually, Krishna grows up to kill Kansa. End of story. Now the question is: Was Kansa's death bound to happen by Krishna? or was it Kansa's attempts to prevent the prophecy that actually led to Krishna's birth who eventually killed him?


By the way, isn't Lord Voldermort and Harry Potter's story is somewhat similar to Kansa and Krishna's? Both have similar prophecy of antagonist's death, and the opposing characters have blood relationships.

Saturday, August 18, 2007

Why Punishment?

...
The Sanjay Dutt trial inspired me to write something about punishment.

Why do we punish?

(Legal) Punishment is a legitimate threat system practiced by society with an intention to keep a social order intact.

The primary reasons for punishments are:

(a) rehabilitation and reform - this is a therapeutic approach to bring the offender into a moral state of mind. In other words, reform the criminal mind with therapy/education and make him a better person so that he/she is no longer harmful to the society,
(b) deterrence - stop someone from future wrong-doing, by giving severe punishment for the activity that is considered harmful to the society. It is commonly believed that when you punish one person for an offense, others in the society also learns from this and avoid doing similar offense/mistake that the offender did,
(c) retribution - this is like taking a revenge in "an eye for an eye" fashion. The focal point in this method of punishment is satisfying the hatred/resentment towards that criminal. The suffering caused on the punishee is considered "good", even if it doesn't have any positive results or effect on the society or punishee ,
(d) incarceration or incapacitation - in order to keep society safe, the criminal is jailed to make sure he/she makes no further direct contact (for a specific time period) with the society. This is practiced by life imprisonments or death sentences in cases of extreme offences.

Laws or ideas of punishment are integral parts of mostly all religions. Biblical religions, for example, have the concept of Lex talionis (retributive justice) with some variations between Judaism, Christian and Islam; while Hindus, Jains, Sikhs and Buddhists philosophies subscribe to the laws of karma (cause and effect) which states that every action has a natural consequence - to put it simply, bad things will happen to bad people.

One thing we should keep in mind, when exercising any mode of punishment, is that the hallmark of a liberal society is to reform and grow, not to punish and take revenge.